St. Celestine V

Peter di Morone spent most of his life trying to disappear. Born in the rugged country of the Abruzzi, he loved silence, fasting, and prayer, withdrew into solitude while still a young man, and built around himself the kind of hard penitential life that drew disciples almost against his will. Out of that hidden life grew the community on Monte Morone that later took his name as the Celestine branch of the Benedictine family. Everything in the first part of his story points away from power. Then came the violent reversal. After a long and scandalous deadlock in the conclave, the cardinals chose the old hermit as pope. Europe greeted the choice with joy, hoping a saint on the throne of Peter would heal the Church.

But holiness in a cave and the government of a divided medieval Church were not the same gift. Celestine was elderly, inexperienced in canon law, easily influenced, and badly suited to a court full of pressure, petitions, factions, and political calculation. He tried to preserve something of his old life even in office, asking for a small cell where he could pray, but the strain only became clearer. Realizing that he could not carry the burden well, he did something almost unheard of and resigned the papacy. His abdication did not bring peace. In the struggle that followed, he was kept under restraint and ended his days in a kind of captivity. The tragedy of the life is not moral failure but misplacement: a truly holy hermit was pulled out of the wilderness, loaded with a task he was never fitted to bear, and broken by it.